musical art | Reviewer: Anonymous
JZ used thE sample to contrast his lyrics.. the children's voices are supposed to ease the listeners guard but the words to the song portray a completely different environment where children would be found. It's art through music.
The sample got me intersted..... | Reviewer: Not typical listener.
Hey y'all, I am a 52 year old white man so I am not JZ's tipical listener. I heard an interveiw of him on NPR's Fresh Air so I know that he had sampled H.K.L.. Right now my little girl is watching "Anny" and I Googled the lyrics to the origional song and this version.
JZ grabbed my attention by using the sample or else I would have never read his lyrics and even tried to learn his message. I don't want to live in the world he describes but I can relate to some of his words. He is a wise man to use the sample to reach a wider audiance IMHO. I wish you all peace and tolerance.
You dont get it about the sampling. It matters not | Reviewer: david hornbuckle
See it matters not. The real creativity is in every single word of these lyrics. The beat of a song doesn't matter. I mean if the content of the lyrics was shit then yeah sampling the its a hard knock life would be a bunch of bull shit. I mean come on. Who the hell listens to Annie any way. It's creative enough to use the sample in the first place. I mean I get pissed when I head some songs that are sampled in todays music but I think it takes an actual good artist to know what the fuck to sample. Now that I say that Jay Z samples a lot of songs in his current music and you know what I'm not totally down with that nor do I think its a particularly awesome sample to use for some of them but the truth is in the lyrics. Because the lyrics are good it doesn't shit on the original song as much as say TLC's dont go chasing water falls which was a shit song to begin with but once I found out it was a sample I was like. Man. mother fuck this song. How lame. Hmmmm...Ughghghg I guess this song is bad ass because who the hell even thinks about "Its a hard knock life" as being a sample. It's not like people listen to the Annie sound track unless they are gay. I mean Yeah. The better point would be that the Annie track was never a REAL "HIT" to begin with so what the fuck. It's more creative to use that irrelevant song to make a real bad ass hit. For instance I head a song with Slim Thug. He sampled " I Ran" by flock of seagulls. Now that was some fucking gay shit. I mean the sample -may- not have been as horrible of a choice if the rapper who laid down verses to it didn't totally lay down some whack ass verses on that shit. Yes. I would say this argument has bits a pieces of sensible irrefutable proofs in it. I'm not gonna write a fucking essay. However, yeah who listens to Annie, the song was Never a "Hit", no one listens to it today wide spread, I mean another point. The fact that he used this sample was genius in itself. The novelty in it. Is amusing in itself. You Know God Damn. How can y'all even argue about THIS particular sample. C'mon. Go a head and shit on " I Ran" by Slim Thug because the rap sucked balls in it. But don't say this type of complete Fuckin shit about this one. I mean shit. The fact that he even had the idea to lay down some bad ass verses about becoming a rich awesome mf - rapper - also ppl trying to keep his ass down- is good enough of a concept in itself to be commendable. Like forever young. I wasn't psyched about him sampling that song at All. It's like. Woah. a little too damned early for me jay-z. However hes got the original guy on it- or I Think thats who the white old guy is singing the sampled hook. However, the fact that the lyrics were tight enough and relevant enough to the original song made it genius bc it pretty much made the "forever young" of the new generation I.E. ummm the generation that listens to rap and the young people who are living their owns lives more so than back in the original songs day. blah blah blah. Yeah.
Hmmm... | Reviewer: Colonel
So sampling is unoriginal? Hmmm... I guess one would also have to say cover songs are unoriginal because it's the same concept (in fact it's almost the exact same thing). And anyone that would argue a cover couldn't be original would be someone that obviously has no idea what they're talking about... of course there are musicians that cover songs merely to steal the glory of the original... there are also musicians that add their own voice to a cover and make the song completely their own (Jimi Hendrix is a good reference point here... as is Coltrane, and really most great jazz musicians).
And anyone that understands anything about music knows that pretty much every genre is built upon teachable, and rather simple forms... so, in essence anyone playing music is stealing from someone else. Even the greatest artists steal, it's impossible not to (if we're just defining stealing as using something you didn't invent).
It's not where it comes from, because that is never a totally original place, that matters. Rap started as dance music essentially, taking liberally from disco, R&B, Soul, Funk and other popular 'black' genres of music. It was never original, nor where the genres it was taking from.
What's most important, though is what an artist is able to do with these recognizable forms, and that is where debate comes in, but to argue flat out that 'sampling' is unoriginal is moronic.
Sampling isnt good | Reviewer: kool
Sampling isnt good, if you take the sample, and dont make anything new, you just basically steal the old idea, and put there a lyrics, thats all.
Thats shit.. compar it to old hip hop tunes.
It had lyrics, own beats, and if used some sample, then made it to look differen, not exactly same as original....
So! | Reviewer: Andrews
So, this song makes me feel good, which.. is really all that matters to me. Sampling doesn't matter, even if it -may- seem to people that its taking the easy way out. Honestly, it isn't. He splashed the new with the old, giving rap a bit of culture. Yes. Culture.
No idea's original | Reviewer: Kome
Sampling makes it all look unoriginal u might say it sounds nice bt wat ya xpect they sampling hit tracks all d same no idea's original and sampling ain't totally wrong as long as u r not a copy cat
Great Song Regardless of Sample | Reviewer: Tinashe Tanyanyiwa
Fuck Jason & anyone like him! Sampling dasnt mean u bein unoriginal t jus means u'v incorporated a concept 2hlp bring out ur own creation & Jigga hs dne gr8 wit songs dat gt samples, remember Dead Presidents? Hardknock Life... Fuckin awesome, applaud him
Shut up about samples. | Reviewer: JES
Using samples does not make the song entirely unoriginal in any way. Claiming that is like claiming DJ Shadow's album Endtoducing, is an unoriginal album, and we all sure as hell know that isn't true.
So just enjoy a great rap song with a cute little sample that is used rather effectively. Goddamn.
Quit Cmplainin | Reviewer: Anonymous
Look rap is a creation, just sometimes we gotta take from the past to create the future. It takes plent of talent to produce these songs. That's just the course, what about the lyrics, verses of em and beats it's a whole process.
Jay'z' "Hard Knock Life | Reviewer: Vit IIkakshli
Sampling may be unoriginal, but the end result sound nothing like the original song from which the sample came. That said, I sure as hell like this rap version better than that cheesy Annie song--Jay-z has taken a childish tune and mad it hip.
Class | Reviewer: Bryan
Brilliant tune, duno who you are 'Jason Weyandt'(if that is your real name) but you think your cool slaggin jay z, FUCK OFF
Rhymin' and Stealin' | Reviewer: Jason Weyandt
Just another song where the producers and the artist involved have stolen a theme or chorus. People please, when are we going to mature and take rap / hip hop to the place where it should be -a creation, not a regurgitation. Who can't take a proven hit or theme and mix it up with lyrics. This is like low budget Kareoke and where paying money to here it. A proven hit is already that, a hit. It takes minimal,if any, talent to produce these songs. Actaully all it takes is the money to pay off the copyright. I know I am just a no-name but have you ever tried to wright lyrics for a rap song...its not to hard, but have you ever tried to come up with an Original beat that actually sounded tight, now that is hard as hell! Don't let these rappers steal from the OG artists and sell it back. I know it sounds good! Of course it does, it was already a huge hit!!!