:: Biography  :: Albums  :: Lyrics

By Pages:   1    2    Add Your New Review About The Song The Reviews about Heart Shaped Box (page 1/ 2) ------ performed by Evanescence Love the ending | Reviewer: Courtney J. | 7/20/09 I love both versions of the song but you all have to admit that Amy killed that ending!! Sure Nirvana had an overall better original (the original always wins, duh) but Nirvana did not end that song like Amy did. So once again, I love the original and the cover but the cover had the better ending in my opinion ummm . . . . . | Reviewer: phil | 2/26/08 heart shaped box (by nirvana) is my favorite song of all time and i just heard the Evanescence version just because i was curious and i dislike it with great intensity i think its because i heard the original first and maybe because im a big nirvana fan Beautiful! | Reviewer: Anonymous | 1/25/08 i heard Evanescence's cover of the song before i actually heard the original but i have to say that i like the acoustic a lot more...but that's probably just because i tend to like acoustics more than the originals. at any rate, this is a beautiful, spur of the moment cover and it's just ignorant not to give both bands the credit they deserve. Priceless advice | Reviewer: Bullets | 11/14/07 I think that for a spur of the moment cover its not bad at all. she can do good covers, Thoughtless was pretty good for a live cover, she can do them well. But if you dont like it don't listen. But dont down her either. Her and her band have done some great things. Priceless advice | Reviewer: Bullets | 11/14/07 I love it, for a spur of the moment cover its very good. Evanescence is a great band, and Amy Lee can do great cover. Thoughtless was a great cover. So if you don't like dont listen. Either way dont bash her. Seriously. | Reviewer: Kori | 10/23/07 Clearly most of you that have reviewed this version of the song have no respect at all. Evanescence did a marvelous job at remaking a song, and she clearly did it for the respect of the singer. I will admit, I do like the original better, but I am in a band myself and plan to remake it (not publically, just locally). So if you think that you can just go bursting out like that and calling her names, saying inappropriate things, etc, you must be dim-witted because you clearly haven't a clue why the band remade it! You have to understand she respected Kurt, she didn't mean to "steal" the song. Get a grip. As towards my own opinion, the lyrics are well matched, and I like the song a lot. Take it easy! | Reviewer: Jenna | 6/24/07 I like the song, and it took me to listen to the Nirvana version of the song.. calm down | Reviewer: ??? | 4/10/07 I do much prefer the original version, but come on she was just paying homage to someone she had great respect for and she did an alright job of it if you ask me. AHH........... WHY???????? | Reviewer: Anonymous | 1/26/07 iLOVE NIRVANA AND EVANESCENCE BUT COME ON ONLY KURT COBAIN CAN SING HIS!! SONGS. THIS IS RIGHT UP THERE WITH THE RED HOT CHILI PEPPERS AND TORI AMOS DOING SMELLS LIKE TEEN SPIRIT!!!!! IT'S JUST NOT RIGHT. Heart Shaped Box | Reviewer: Gabbie | 6/9/06 I think the Nirvana Cover was Awesome.. It's not like she went off and said, THIS IS MY SONG.. It was during an interview and they decided to play it as a spur of the moment thing. She has a beautiful voice and I think she gave it what it deserved on an acoustic level.. For anyone not to respect that.. Is just closed minded and stupid. Add Your New Review About The Song By Pages:   1    2